Committal Hearings in NSW – What Happens Under the Current Law?

If you have been charged with a serious criminal offence in New South Wales, your matter may proceed through the committal process in the Local Court before being transferred to the District Court or Supreme Court.

The committal process changed significantly on 30 April 2018 with the introduction of the Early Appropriate Guilty Pleas (EAGP) reforms.

At Orr Legal, principal solicitor Nichole Orr represents clients facing serious criminal charges, including committal proceedings and District Court trials, in Maitland, Newcastle and throughout NSW.

What Is a Committal Hearing?

Historically, a committal hearing involved a Magistrate considering whether the prosecution evidence was sufficient to justify committing an accused person for trial.

Under the current NSW legislation, a Magistrate is no longer required to decide whether the prosecution evidence is sufficient before committing a matter for trial.

Instead, the prosecution is responsible for reviewing the evidence and certifying the charges that will proceed.

Committal proceedings remain an important stage of serious criminal matters, but their primary functions have changed.

What Happens During Committal Proceedings?

Under the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW), the current process ordinarily involves:

1. Service of the Brief of Evidence

The prosecution provides the evidence relied upon to support the allegations.

This may include witness statements, police interviews, electronic communications, CCTV footage and forensic evidence.

2. Charge Certification

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) reviews the evidence and certifies the charges that will proceed.

The prosecution may amend, withdraw or replace charges following its review.

3. Case Conference

Where the accused is legally represented, the prosecution and defence will ordinarily participate in a case conference.

The conference provides an opportunity to discuss the evidence, consider representations concerning the charges and explore whether an appropriate resolution is available.

4. Committal for Trial or Sentence

Following the required procedures, the Local Court ordinarily commits the accused to the District Court or Supreme Court.

Where a guilty plea is accepted, the matter proceeds to sentence. Otherwise, the matter generally proceeds towards trial.

Can Witnesses Still Be Cross-Examined During Committal?

Yes, but only in limited circumstances.

Under sections 82–85 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW), an application may be made for a prosecution witness to attend and give oral evidence.

An application can only be made after the charge certificate has been filed.

Where the parties do not consent to the witness attending, the court must be satisfied that substantial reasons exist, in the interests of justice, for the witness to give oral evidence.

Additional statutory restrictions apply to particular categories of witnesses.

Witness examination is therefore not a routine part of committal proceedings.

Can Charges Be Withdrawn During the Committal Process?

Yes.

The prosecution may withdraw charges or agree to proceed on different charges following consideration of the evidence and representations made by the defence.

The case conference process provides an important opportunity to discuss whether an appropriate resolution can be reached.

However, the accused is not required to plead guilty simply because a case conference takes place.

The prosecution retains the burden of proving criminal charges beyond reasonable doubt at trial.

What Happens After Committal?

If the matter is committed for trial, it proceeds to the District Court or Supreme Court for arraignment and further case management.

Trial preparation may involve additional disclosure, conferences with counsel, expert evidence and pre-trial applications.

Where a guilty plea is entered and accepted, the matter ordinarily proceeds to sentence.

Eligible guilty pleas may attract a sentencing discount under the applicable EAGP legislation.

How Orr Legal Can Assist

At Orr Legal, principal solicitor Nichole Orr personally manages serious criminal matters from the early stages of proceedings through to their conclusion.

Orr Legal assists clients with:

  • Reviewing prosecution briefs and assessing the evidence.
  • Advising on the charges and available defences.
  • Making representations to the ODPP.
  • Preparing for and participating in EAGP case conferences.
  • Advising on guilty pleas and sentencing consequences.
  • Briefing criminal barristers where appropriate.
  • Preparing matters for District Court trials and sentencing proceedings.

Nichole provides direct advice and strategic representation throughout the criminal proceedings.

Facing Committal Proceedings in NSW?

If you have been charged with a serious criminal offence, obtaining legal advice early can help you understand the charges, the prosecution evidence and your available options.

Orr Legal provides criminal defence representation in Maitland, Newcastle, the Hunter Region and courts throughout NSW.

Book a confidential Criminal Law Consultation & Case Assessment with principal solicitor Nichole Orr.